New 409A valuations for Indian startups with a US (Delaware) parent.New: 409A for US-parent startupsSee how it works →

Methodology

DCF or comparable companies:
which does your valuation need?

The two common methods answer different questions. A credible report knows which question it is answering.

  • CA Devansh ShahRegistered Valuer
  • Nov 2026Last reviewed
  • 6 minReading time
In this article
General information, not a valuation opinion or tax advice

§ 1

Each method is an argument

A discounted cash flow asserts that a business is worth the cash it will generate, discounted at a rate that reflects the risk of receiving it. It is an argument about the future.

The comparable company method asserts that a business is worth what the market pays today for similar earnings or revenue, after adjusting for size, growth, margin and liquidity. It is an argument about the present.

§ 2

When the future is the best evidence

DCF should carry the conclusion when the business has economics no peer multiple captures, such as a contract book, a regulatory position or a turnaround, or when genuine peers barely exist. The condition is that the projections can be defended. Where terminal value contributes most of the result, the valuation rests on one long-term assumption, and that is where a reviewer will look.

§ 3

When the market is the best evidence

Comparables should carry the conclusion when liquid peers or recent transactions speak clearly. The failure is false comparability: companies that share an industry label but differ in customers, capital intensity and growth. In India’s thinner listed universe, peer sets are often stretched too far.

§ 4

Why credible reports triangulate

The ICAI Valuation Standards and IVS expect each applicable approach to be considered and the results reconciled. The reconciliation is where a reviewer looks first, because it is where reasoning cannot be templated.

About the author

CA Devansh Shah

Chartered Accountant and IBBI Registered Valuer (Securities or Financial Assets). Founder, Fintellectual Valuation, Ahmedabad.

This article is general information. It is not a valuation opinion or tax advice.

Contact

A question specific to your situation?

Put it to the valuer. You will hear back within one business day.

Discuss a mandate Talk to a valuer