New 409A valuations for Indian startups with a US (Delaware) parent.New: 409A for US-parent startupsSee how it works →

ESOP · Compliance

Three mistakes that get ESOP valuations
rejected by auditors.

None of them are unusual, and all of them can be avoided at the outset.

  • CA Devansh ShahRegistered Valuer
  • Nov 2026Last reviewed
  • 6 minReading time
In this article
General information, not a valuation opinion or tax advice

§ 1

Reusing a stale valuation across grant dates

An ESOP valuation is an opinion as at a date. When options are granted months later on the same number, and a round, a large contract or a regulatory approval has intervened, the Ind AS 102 expense is understated. Auditors check the gap between valuation date and grant date, and what happened in between.

Before each grant, ask whether anything has occurred that a buyer would pay more or less for. If so, refresh the valuation. If not, record why.

§ 2

One number used for two purposes

Ind AS 102 needs the fair value of the option at grant date. The employee’s perquisite under Section 17 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 depends on the fair market value of the share on the exercise date, under the Income-tax Rules, 2026. Different purposes, different standards of value, often different dates.

State the purpose in the engagement scope. Where there are two purposes, produce two clearly labelled conclusions from one consistent analysis.

§ 3

Inputs asserted rather than derived

Audit review begins with the inputs: volatility, expected life, the risk-free rate and the underlying share value. Volatility should come from an identified peer set, expected life from vesting terms and exercise behaviour, and the share value from a triangulated analysis.

About the author

CA Devansh Shah

Chartered Accountant and IBBI Registered Valuer (Securities or Financial Assets). Founder, Fintellectual Valuation, Ahmedabad.

This article is general information. It is not a valuation opinion or tax advice.

Contact

A question specific to your situation?

Put it to the valuer. You will hear back within one business day.

Discuss a mandate Talk to a valuer