New 409A valuations for Indian startups with a US (Delaware) parent.New: 409A for US-parent startupsSee how it works →

ESOP valuation and advisory

Three dates, three purposes.
One defensible share value.

Grant-date fair values under Ind AS 102, exercise-date values for perquisite tax, and the scheme that connects them. Prepared so that the auditor, the employee and the tax authority each see a number built for their purpose.

  • IBBI RVSecurities or Financial Assets
  • Ind AS 102Grant-date fair value
  • Section 17Perquisite value
  • SchemeDrafting and implementation
Which value, for whom
At scheme creation
Share value to set the exercise price
At grant
Option fair value for the Ind AS 102 expense
At exercise
Share FMV for the employee’s perquisite
Each year
Pool, vesting and expense reviewed

Different numbers, built from one analysis.

Labelled by purpose in every report

Overview

What is ESOP valuation?

ESOP valuation covers the values an employee stock option plan needs over its life: the share value at grant, the fair value of the option itself for the accounts, and the fair market value at exercise for employee taxation.

Each date and purpose has its own standard of value. Mixing them, or relying on a stale report, is the most common reason auditors reject an ESOP valuation.

Mandates

Where an ESOP needs a valuation.

  • Companies Act, 2013

    New scheme or pool

    A scheme under Section 62(1)(b), read with Rule 12 of the Share Capital and Debentures Rules, needs a supportable share value to set exercise prices. Listed companies follow the SEBI SBEB and Sweat Equity Regulations, 2021.

  • Ind AS 102

    Grant cycles and audit

    Each grant needs a grant-date fair value for each tranche and vesting schedule, with inputs the statutory auditor can trace.

  • Income-tax Act, 2025

    Exercise and withholding

    The employee’s perquisite under Section 17 is based on fair market value on the exercise date, determined under the Income-tax Rules, 2026. The employer withholds under Section 392 (formerly section 192).

  • Transactions

    Funding rounds and exits

    Rounds often require a formal scheme or a pool top-up. Exits and buy-backs require values for acceleration and cash-out.

Transactions and returns for FY 2025-26 and earlier remain governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961 and the Income-tax Rules, 1962. Provisions are confirmed against the notified text at scoping.

Regulations and standards

Which regulations and standards apply.

Companies Act, 2013

Section 62(1)(b) and Rule 12 of the Share Capital Rules: issue of shares under an employee stock option scheme.

Ind AS 102

Share-based payment: grant-date fair value of options, usually by Black-Scholes or a binomial model.

Income-tax Act, 2025

Perquisite value on exercise, at fair market value determined by a Registered Valuer for unlisted shares.

SEBI (SBEB & SE) Regulations, 2021

For listed companies and their employee benefit schemes.

ICAI Guidance Note

Accounting for share-based payments for companies not on Ind AS.

Provisions are confirmed against the notified text at scoping. See credentials and frameworks.

Approach

Inputs derived, not asserted.

Audit review of an ESOP valuation starts with the inputs. Each one is sourced, and the reasoning is written down.

InputHow we derive itWhat the auditor checks
Underlying share valueIncome and market approaches, reconciled, and consistent with any recent round.Whether the share value matches other valuations on file for the same period.
Option modelBlack-Scholes for plain vanilla terms; binomial or lattice where vesting or exercise conditions require it.Whether the model fits the plan’s terms.
VolatilityHistorical volatility of an identified listed peer set, over a period matching expected life.The peer set and the period used.
Expected lifeReasoned from vesting, exercise windows and expected employee behaviour.Whether it is reasoned or simply the contractual term.
Risk-free rate and dividendsGovernment securities yield for the matching tenor; dividend expectation from policy and history.The source and the date of each figure.

Scheme drafting

A scheme drafted with valuation in view.

  1. 01Pool size and dilution, modelled against the cap table
  2. 02Eligibility, vesting schedules and cliffs
  3. 03Exercise price policy and its valuation basis
  4. 04Exercise windows, lapse and forfeiture
  5. 05Treatment on exit, liquidity events and termination
  6. 06Board and shareholder approvals required

Most ESOP problems at grant or exercise trace back to how the scheme was drafted. We structure the commercial and valuation terms with the company, and work with its legal counsel on the scheme document and approvals.

Implementation

Keeping grants, accounts and tax consistent.

  1. 01Grant letters and grant registers
  2. 02Grant-date fair values for each tranche
  3. 03Ind AS 102 expense schedules for the auditor
  4. 04Exercise-date values for perquisite tax
  5. 05Employee explanation of how the options work
  6. 06Annual review of pool, vesting and lapses

After approval, the scheme has to run without each grant becoming a separate exercise. We support its operation year on year.

Professional insight

The most common reason an ESOP valuation is questioned is a date problem: a value from one date used for a grant on another, after something material happened in between.

Who signs
The valuer who scopes and leads the work
Legal drafting
Completed with your counsel or company secretary

Why Fintellectual

Why appoint Fintellectual Valuation.

  • Single point of responsibility

    The valuer who signs

    CA Devansh Shah scopes, leads and signs every mandate. You are never passed between teams.

  • Registered for the purpose

    IBBI RV and Chartered Accountant

    Registered Valuer for Securities or Financial Assets, and a member of ICAI. Numbers are stated on every report.

  • Independent

    Valuation only

    No audit, no investment role and no incentive to reach a number other than the one the evidence supports.

  • Built for scrutiny

    For the reader who tests it

    Grant, accounting and exercise valuations kept consistent with each other, with every option-pricing input sourced and explained.

About CA Devansh Shah →

Questions

Asked before most instructions.

Which value does the auditor need, and which does the employee’s tax need?

The auditor needs the fair value of the option at grant date under Ind AS 102. The employee’s perquisite is based on the fair market value of the share on the exercise date under the Income-tax Rules, 2026. They are different numbers for different purposes, and the report keeps them separate.

Who may value unlisted shares for perquisite purposes?

The Income-tax Rules prescribe who may determine fair market value for this purpose. We confirm the requirement against the notified text at scoping and coordinate with any other required signatory.

How often should grant-date values be refreshed?

For every grant cycle, and whenever a funding round or material event changes the underlying share value.

Can you draft the scheme as well?

Yes. We structure the commercial and valuation terms and work with your legal counsel on the scheme document, approvals and filings.

Contact

Discuss the mandate with the valuer who will lead it.

Share the purpose, the parties and the date that matters. You will hear back from CA Devansh Shah within one business day.

Discuss a mandate Talk to a valuer