409A valuation (US)
A US strike price
for a business run from India.
Common stock valuations under Section 409A for Delaware parents whose team and operations are in India. Prepared with the parent’s preference stack and the Indian subsidiary’s ESOP, FEMA and transfer pricing positions in view.
- IBBI RVSecurities or Financial Assets
- Section 409AUS Internal Revenue Code
- AICPAPractice Aid allocation
- 12 monthsTypical validity
- Value driver
- The Indian operating business
- Securities
- Preferred stack at the US parent
- Parallel positions
- Indian ESOP, FEMA, transfer pricing
- Refresh
- After a round or within twelve months
The US and Indian numbers should tell the same story.
Overview
What is a 409A valuation?
A 409A valuation determines the fair market value of a US company’s common stock, so that stock options can be granted at or above that value. It applies to Indian startups that have flipped to, or were set up under, a US (often Delaware) parent.
The value starts with the enterprise, usually the Indian operating business, and is then allocated across preferred and common stock with adjustments for lack of marketability. A current 409A is generally refreshed every twelve months or after a material event such as a new round.
Mandates
When a 409A is needed.
Section 409A
First option grants
Before the first grants under the parent’s equity plan, so options are granted at or above fair market value.
After a financing
Priced round
A new round usually makes the existing 409A stale.
Annual refresh
Twelve-month cycle
At least every twelve months, or sooner after a material event.
Secondaries
Founder or employee sales
Secondary transactions that may inform common stock value.
Regulations and standards
Which regulations and standards apply.
US Internal Revenue Code, Section 409A
Options granted below fair market value can trigger immediate taxation and penalties for the holder.
Treasury Regulations under 409A
Set out reasonable valuation methods and the presumption available for an independent appraisal.
ASC 718
US GAAP accounting for stock-based compensation, which uses the common stock value.
AICPA Accounting and Valuation Guide
Valuation of privately-held-company equity securities issued as compensation, including allocation methods.
Indian regulations
FEMA and Income-tax positions on the Indian subsidiary, reconciled where the same business is valued.
Provisions are confirmed against the notified text at scoping. See credentials and frameworks.
Approach
From enterprise value to common stock.
| Step | Method | What we test |
|---|---|---|
| Enterprise value | Income, market and recent-transaction evidence, centred on the Indian operating business. | Consistency with the latest round and the plan. |
| Equity allocation | Option-pricing method, PWERM or a hybrid, depending on the exit outlook. | The preference stack and conversion terms. |
| Marketability discount | Applied to common stock, supported by the chosen model. | Expected time to liquidity. |
US tax and legal advice should be obtained from the company’s US advisers. Our role is the independent valuation.
The report
What the report contains.
- 01Valuation date and purpose
- 02Company, capital structure and rights of each class
- 03Enterprise value analysis
- 04Allocation to common stock
- 05Marketability discount and its support
- 06Concluded fair market value per common share
Engagement
How a mandate runs.
- Day 0–1ScopingPurpose, valuation date, basis of value and deliverable confirmed in an engagement letter, after an independence check.
- Days 1–3InformationCap table, charter, latest financing documents and the plan, then a session with the founders.
- Days 5–7Indicative viewApproaches applied and assumptions tested. The indicative view is discussed with you before the report is finalised.
- Days 10–15Signed reportSigned by the Registered Valuer, who also answers later questions from reviewers.
Why Fintellectual
Why appoint Fintellectual Valuation.
Single point of responsibility
The valuer who signs
CA Devansh Shah scopes, leads and signs every mandate. You are never passed between teams.
Registered for the purpose
IBBI RV and Chartered Accountant
Registered Valuer for Securities or Financial Assets, and a member of ICAI. Numbers are stated on every report.
Independent
Valuation only
No audit, no investment role and no incentive to reach a number other than the one the evidence supports.
Built for scrutiny
For the reader who tests it
The Indian operating business is analysed by a valuer who knows it, and the 409A is reconciled with the Indian FEMA and tax valuations.
Questions
Asked before most instructions.
How long is a 409A valid?
Generally up to twelve months, unless a material event such as a financing occurs sooner.
Can the same work support our Indian ESOP?
The enterprise analysis can, but Indian requirements have their own valuation dates and rules. Each output is prepared separately so that both stand on their own.
Contact
Discuss the mandate with the valuer who will lead it.
Share the purpose, the parties and the date that matters. You will hear back from CA Devansh Shah within one business day.